Now, as yet the guys investigating "Directive 19" and "Honor Denied" hadn't heard anything else about a Deiter Hoffmann EXCEPT this reference...
THEN John Moore was sent some documents. Strangely enough, he was sent them by an individual on AHF - called "Amsel" - who hasn't figured in things yet...
BUT IT'S TIME HE DID...
http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=89755&p=935455#p935455
"Hi Booklover, I would recommend "Directive 19 The Memoirs of Sturmbannfuhrer Rolf Otto Schiller". It covers the career of an SS officer who worked for Eichmann, Heydrich and Himmler."
And just LOOK WHO AGREED WITH HIM!!!
"I'd recommend Directive 19 too. Very interesting book."
Cavet25!!!
But what ELSE has "Amsel" said on AHF???
"George, Rolf Otto Schiller has been called fictional every time he has been discussed on this website. I am a little disappointed that the research on him has been cursory. Other researchers have found his records."
REALLY??? Perhaps you'd care to point us at ONE SINGLE "EXPERT" who has EVER FOUND ROLF OTTO SCHILLER OR ANYONE EQATING TO HIM IN ANY RECORDS ANYWHEREE???
Strangely enough - in THAT thread...such an expert SUDDENLY appeared!!! AND in the VERY next posting...
"For those who smell a rat, you might want to reconsider the company you keep. I agree that a lot of "research" here appears to be cursory at best as Amsel points out. I haven't read the other threads about this guy being "fictitious" but I looked deeper than the Dienstalterliste and Field Men lists and found him. The DALS is often unreliable and I find it hard to believe that serious researchers use this as the "only" source of verification."
And just WHO was this noted "Expert" who found Rolf Otto Schiller in the historivcal expert when a whole raft of published historian couldn't???
CAVET25!!!
Who we ALL now know was Paul K. Harker himself! So even on AHF Harker was posing as a so-called "expert" to try and deflect genuine and well-founded criticism of his book!
BUT...let's not get TOO far from Deiter Hoffmann JUST yet...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment